Mr. Campbell and Mr. Granger do not agree !!

[justobserving]

Mr. Campbell and Mr. Granger do not agree on their final regular season rankings ... What do you think ?

Mr. Granger's
Rank _ School ________ Record
1 Rankin ……………….. 8-2
2 Ira ……………………. 10-0
3 Water Valley ………… 10-0
4 Valley …………………. 9-1
5 Borden County …….... 9-1
6 Throckmorton ……….. 9-0
7 Petersburg …………… 9-1
8 Sands ………………… 8-2
9 Crowell ……………….. 8-2
10 Meadow ……………… 6-3

Mr. Campbells's
1 Throckmorton ……….. 9-0
2 Ira ……………………. 10-0
3 Borden County ……… 9-1
4 Turkey Valley ………… 9-1
5 Water Valley …………. 10-0
6 Rankin ………………… 8-2
7 Petersburg ……...……. 9-1
8 Sands …………………. 8-2
9 Oakwood …………….. 10-0
10 Zephyr ……….……… 10-0

Feel free to comment on any other ranking system we have going. I know of one other on the board.....

 

[rainjacktx]

I think Campbell has Zephyr and Oakwood ranked way too high.

At this point, once you get to the top 5 or 6, I think the teams are interchangeable. I can't remember when there has been such a rotation in the top 5 from week to week.

All this ranking stuff has about another week left before it's all meaningless anyway.

 

[CowboyP]

I agree that Campbell has Oakwood & Zehpyr too high. I expect Aquilla to take Oakwood out of it.

 

[dawgfan23]

Mr. Campbell's system seems to be more in line with the college poll system. They give more credit for win-loss records. You don't typically find 4-6 or 5-5 teams in the top 20 of those polls. We can all find fault with either poll but whether we agree or not with them, they are fun to discuss.

 

[red88]

1.IRA 10-0
2.WATER VALLEY 10-0
3.RANKIN 8-2
4.THROCKMORTON 9-0
5.VALLEY 9-1
6.BORDEN COUNTY 9-1
7.PETERSBURG 9-1
8.CROWELL 8-2
9.ZEPHYR 10-0
10. SANDS 8-2

 

[granger]

I think we can agree the top-6 are the best six teams, just what order we put them in will differ....

I love the playoffs... unfortunately I won't get to see any games THIS week, but more on that later...

 

[pojocrusader]

i can believe Mr grangers rankings over Campbell's because it actually takes strength of schedule in consideration not just undefeated

 

[kbjoe1]

i think that if healthy the top 6-8 of the west would be tough for t-rock. in past the east has had this same kind of strength against the west. good luck to all and health for all the youngmen that strive to reach the goal