These are by no means a no brainer, and I'm from one of the four. So I understand the division between the two of you.
I would have to say look at the facts. Follett/Water Valley is going to be a GREAT game. Maybe the best regular season match up of the year, but I know I love watching a football game that means something. Follett/Water Valley has nothing more to it then just being a great game, it can't even be enjoyed with the hope of a rematch in November.
That is why I personally am going to the Throck/Crowell game. It should be a great game, both teams know how to put points on the board and as if the game wasn't going to be good enough just given the caliber of the two teams on the field, you can also watch it and keep in mind there is a possible rematch next month. I believe this game is the true begining of something special for both teams.
On a side note, those who say Crowell is going to get "thumped" should consider that this game was decided by 30 points last year BUT FELT CLOSER THAN 30 and was a great game to the end. It was the first test for Throck on their way to their second straight title. Also much like this year the loser last year got Ira in the first round another game that was great. Crowell has showed they can hang with the best, and although I won't promise a victory, I can say that to assume Crowell isn't going to be their when the final horn blows in the 4th, to me, seems to be an ignorant assumtion. MY VOTE CROWELL OVER THROCKMORTON (POSSIBLY) IS TOO GOOD A OPPORTUNITY TO PASS UP. Fight to the end CATS!