Last Friday we kicked an onside which first contacted the ground at about 5 yards, dribbled, and then popped up coming down at about 17 yards. A player from the other team fielded the ball and was immediately hit by our player. The timing was close. The receiving team was able to hold on to the ball.
We got a penalty for not allowing the receiver of the ball room to make the catch. Which seemed like a punt thing, but not kick off thing since the ball is live at that point. There was no fair catch signal given.
Questions.
1. Can you even make a fair catch if the ball hits the ground first?
2. Was this a correct penalty assuming the ball arrived before our player hit the other player?
3. Was this a correct penalty assuming the ball arrived after our player hit the other player?
4. Was this a correct penalty assuming the ball and our player arrived simultaneously?
We got a penalty for not allowing the receiver of the ball room to make the catch. Which seemed like a punt thing, but not kick off thing since the ball is live at that point. There was no fair catch signal given.
Questions.
1. Can you even make a fair catch if the ball hits the ground first?
2. Was this a correct penalty assuming the ball arrived before our player hit the other player?
3. Was this a correct penalty assuming the ball arrived after our player hit the other player?
4. Was this a correct penalty assuming the ball and our player arrived simultaneously?