Hi Coach,
What is your outlook for next year? Will you have Manny returning players? We are looking for teams that would match up well. Not looking for lopsided game either way.
Some may some "dumb", but this has been used successfully in professional soccer by the English Football League.
Is you want the best teams to have to play, then you have to try to put them in the same division. Similar to suggestions to just have one division.
The benefit of multiple...
I'd make three divisions, but not based on enrollment. It would be based on last seasons performance with the best teams in d1. Then each year the 10 best teams in division 2 and 3 are promoted up and the ten worst teams in division 1 and 2 are demoted down.