| Date | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9/24/04 | Paducah | 48 | Crowell | 7 |
| 9/23/05 | Paducah | 51 | Crowell | 25 |
| 10/27/06 | Paducah | 42 | Crowell | 12 |
| 10/26/07 | Crowell | 36 | Paducah | 20 |
| 11/7/08 | Paducah | 44 | Crowell | 38 |
| 11/6/09 | Crowell | 54 | Paducah | 40 |
| 10/29/10 | Paducah | 52 | Crowell | 48 |
| 10/28/11 | Crowell | 52 | Paducah | 6 |
| 9/12/14 | Crowell | 80 | Paducah | 27 |
| 9/11/15 | Crowell | 61 | Paducah | 13 |
| 11/2/18 | Paducah | 87 | Crowell | 59 |
| 11/1/19 | Crowell | 32 | Paducah | 28 |
| 10/23/20 | Crowell | 68 | Paducah | 50 |
| 10/22/21 | Crowell | 32 | Paducah | 24 |
| 10/28/22 | Paducah | 55 | Crowell | 8 |
| 10/27/23 | Crowell | 44 | Paducah | 28 |