| Date | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10/8/04 | Paducah | 56 | Motley County | 6 |
| 10/7/05 | Paducah | 76 | Motley County | 46 |
| 9/17/10 | Paducah | 74 | Motley County | 44 |
| 9/16/11 | Motley County | 46 | Paducah | 0 |
| 9/21/12 | Motley County | 54 | Paducah | 52 |
| 9/20/13 | Paducah | 107 | Motley County | 68 |
| 10/31/14 | Motley County | 64 | Paducah | 48 |
| 10/30/15 | Motley County | 58 | Paducah | 55 |
| 9/28/18 | Motley County | 86 | Paducah | 60 |
| 9/27/19 | Paducah | 88 | Motley County | 46 |
| 11/1/24 | Motley County | 52 | Paducah | 34 |
| 10/31/25 | Motley County | 45 | Paducah | 44 |